The Minimum Protein Staple? – Towards ‘bio’-Baldwin's rules via inter-phosphosite linking in the MEK1 activation loop

In small molecule organic chemistry, the heuristic insight into ring-forming processes that was enabled by Baldwin's rules some 50 years ago proved a step-change in the role of mechanistically guided synthesis. It created a lens upon and marker of fundamental stereoelectronic and conformation-guided chemical processes. However, despite the widespread role of stereoelectronics and conformational control in Biology, no equivalent coherent exploitation of trapped, ring-forming processes yet exists in biomolecules. In the development of a minimal ring-closing process in intact proteins that might prove suitable in a coherent rule-set, we have tested endo-trig ring-closing conjugate thioether lanthionine (Lan) –CH2–S–CH2- formation as a limiting cyclization. Spontaneous Lan formation in proteins is rare if not non-existent and when found in natural product cyclic peptides it requires the mediation of corresponding biosynthetic enzymes as well as productive reactive conformations to guide it. Here, we show that within a conformationally flexible and functionally important protein loop – the MAPK kinase phosphorylation-targeted activation loop – Lan ring-closing is possible. Ring-closing proves to be critically dependent on the location of a trig electrophilic site in just one of two regioisomeric potential precursors to allow phosphosite-to-phosphosite ‘stapling’. This first example of spontaneous protein thioether ring-closing/‘stapling’ and its accessibility from just one precursor (despite the potential for both to form an identical ‘staple’) now reveals the potential for Lan formation not only as an accessible form of minimal stapling in proteins but also as an exquisitely sensitive probe of associated protein geometries. We suggest that the use of this (as well as the development of other such, intramolecular protein traps that are dependent on inherent protein-controlled reactivity rather than forced crosslinking) may allow the broader trapping and mapping of relevant, even minor, protein states. In this way, protein ring formation may enable a form of extended ‘bio-Baldwin's rules' that help to delineate relevant protein conformational space.